Camping Product Review
I’ve had this tent for almost eight months and am ready to talk about the Moosejaw Comfortress 4 from Walmart. Here is the link to this tent if you’re interested in it. Spoiler alert: I like it.
I love having a big enough tent to not feel cramped. I want to have room for my cot, a table, a seat, and my personal gear. I also want it to hold up to winds and to stay dry in rain (don’t we all?). I’d love for it to be cool in hot weather and warm in cold weather, but I’m starting to talk about an RV now.

The Comfortress 4 is designed as a car-camping tent. It weighs 20 pounds, so it’s definitely one for those trips where you don’t have to pack it in very far. It’s an 8ft x 8ft cabin with a 6ft vestibule at the entrance. It stands 6 feet tall in the center, which means I can stand up inside as I’m getting dressed.
MY FAVORITE THINGS:
- The vestibule is awesome! As Scoutmaster, this is a great place to sit “privately” to chat with scouts or friends, well in view of others for safety. the front and side doors zip open to make it light and airy, and the third side is a window that zips down to reveal a screen. There’s room for two chairs comfortably, even when everything is zipped closed in the weather.
This spacious vestibule also is a good place to park shoes so you don’t have to try to navigate taking them off inside the tent. I like to set up a chair in the vestibule for taking off shoes, and then step on it.
Wet or rainy? You can still park your shoes outside the door in the vestibule. Add a floor mat or piece of Tyvek for ground protection. - The tent bag has a large zipper opening from end to end, so that you’re not having to fight the tent to get it packed in. The bag is large enough for me to add a tarp for extra floor protection.
- The door inside the tent has a zippered window to provide privacy or air movement.
- Rain and weather protection: This weekend rained and sleeted (the snow came after I’d taken it down) and it was windy! My tent stayed nice and dry, while my scouts had a lot more water issues. I used more guy lines than I sometimes do, and nothing was flapping in the wind. And the roof is sloped in a way that doesn’t collect water, even in a downpour.

THE DOWNSIDES:
- While the tent goes up easily with three poles — two cross over the top from corner to corner and fit into cups on each corner, while the third supports the top crossways — the rain fly is a challenge in the light of day. Now do it in the dark and the rain.
You can do this by yourself but it’ll take 45 minutes, even when you know what you’re doing. A second set of hands helps a lot, usually to hold onto the pole that supports the front part of the vestibule as you pull the guy ropes to secure it. - No footprint: There’s no footprint with this tent, and I do like the extra protection for the floor. But no real worries — I bought an 8×10 tarp. This is nice because I get an extra two feet of floorspace in my vestibule that’s covered and safe. So is that really a negative? The tarp even fits into the bag.
- I wish there was a way to close the windows from inside, but it’s been a long time since I slept in any tent where you can do that. As you can see from the troop campout photo above, the rain fly can be folded back to increase airflow, but if you want to get dressed, you have to go close it.
- It does get hot inside the tent, thanks to the dark color. But want to go rest in the shelter? Go to the ventilated vestibule.
- Size: This is a big tent, and the rain fly and vestibule make it even bigger. It seems like a lot of work for a one-night outing, but it’s so comfortable you can forgive yourself for the indulgence. And let’s please not discuss trying to find a place to dry it after a winter camping trip.
This weekend had some of the worst weather I’ve camped in. By the end of the weekend the entire campground was a sloppy mess of standing water and mud. My Comfortress 4 stayed dry all the way around, despite the small stream running exactly under my tent. (Why did I not take a picture?!?!) What I do have is a photo that one of our scouts took of the general state of the campsite.

No drips from the windows, no leaks at the corners or through the floor, no mud tracked in the door. NO MUD INSIDE, friends. I didn’t even feel a breeze inside as the wind blew all around. Temperatures were down to about 33 degrees at the coldest.
For comfort and function, I give this an A.
For ease of setup, it’s probably a C.
For packing it up to put it away, it’s another A.
For inside air circulation, it’s a B-.
The vestibule gives it an A+ for convenient features.
For subtlety, F-, but since that doesn’t actually matter to me, I’m dropping that score.
This is an excellent tent for Scoutmaster Jenny of Noblesville BSA Troop 222 for Girls. Perfect for long-term camping like summer camp but great for a weekend camp as well.

























































































